A Polished Adirondack Favorite with Coastal flair: Dining at Cafe Adirondack
Tucked along Route 9 in the hamlet of Pottersville, Cafe Adirondack is one of those rare Adirondack restaurants that manages to feel both comfortably familiar and quietly elevated. It’s the kind of place locals recommend without hesitation, visitors discover by happy accident, and regulars return to again and again—often ordering the same beloved dishes, because why mess with perfection?
Perfectly grilled steak paired with scallops. All photos courtesy Cafe Adirondack.
Located between Chestertown and Schroon Lake (and just a few minutes off of I-87), Cafe Adirondack has built its reputation on polished American cuisine with strong coastal and Southern influences, delivered in a warm, welcoming setting that feels more like a neighborhood favorite than a “special occasion only” destination—though it certainly rises to the occasion when you want it to.
A menu rooted in comfort, refined with confidence.
At its core, Cafe Adirondack excels at classic American fare done exceptionally well, with seafood and options for various dietary preferences, including gluten-free, vegan and vegetarian dishes, ensuring all guests find something satisfying.
On a recent visit, several standout dishes reinforced exactly why this restaurant continues to earn its loyal following.
Fresh, delicious seafood dishes are a standout.
The She Crab Soup is nothing short of extraordinary—silky, rich, and deeply comforting, with a luxurious texture and layered flavor that hints at sherry and coastal tradition. It’s the kind of soup that makes you pause mid-spoonful and look up, just to acknowledge how good it really is.
Equally memorable are the Bang Bang Shrimp, crispy and perfectly cooked, tossed in a creamy, sweet-heat sauce that delivers just enough kick without overpowering the delicate shrimp. It’s a dish that bridges the gap between indulgent and addictive—and one that appears again and again in customer reviews for good reason.
The rest of the menu continues to impress with confident execution across proteins and preparations:
Parm Trio, a generous and satisfying sampler for anyone torn between favorites
12 oz Strip Steak, cooked precisely, with bold flavor and classic steakhouse appeal
Seared Ahi Tuna, clean, fresh, and expertly handled
Crab Cakes, packed with crab rather than filler, crisp on the outside and tender within
Balsamic Chicken, a crowd-pleaser that balances sweetness, acidity, and savory depth
Classic chicken parm served over fettuccine.
This is a kitchen that understands restraint—letting quality ingredients and sound technique speak for themselves rather than chasing trends.
Wine, beer, and the art of keeping it simple.
Cafe Adirondack keeps its beverage program intentionally focused, serving wine and beer only—and doing so well. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, offering affordable options that pair beautifully with both seafood and steak, while the beer selection includes local craft brews alongside familiar favorites.
This streamlined approach fits with the restaurant’s ethos: thoughtful, unfussy, and centered on the dining experience. You won’t find an overcomplicated cocktail menu here—and you won’t miss it.
The Wine Room: Private dining with Adirondack charm.
One of Cafe Adirondack’s most appealing features is its private dining space, the Wine Room, which comfortably seats up to 25 guests. It’s an ideal option for small celebrations, milestone birthdays, rehearsal dinners, business gatherings, or intimate group dinners where conversation and good food make fond memories.
The Wine Room adds another layer of versatility to the restaurant, allowing it to serve not just individual diners and couples, but also groups seeking a relaxed yet polished setting.
Who will love dining at Cafe Adirondack?
Cafe Adirondack attracts a wonderfully diverse crowd, which speaks volumes about its broad appeal. It’s especially well-suited for:
Couples looking for a cozy but refined dinner spot
Food-focused travelers exploring the Adirondacks who want something beyond pub fare
Locals celebrate special occasions without leaving the region.
Seafood lovers craving well-executed coastal classics
Groups and families who appreciate quality without pretense
What customers and reviewers are saying.
Consistently, reviews highlight friendly, attentive service and a menu that delivers on its promises. Guests often praise the seafood dishes in particular—especially the She Crab Soup and crab cakes—while noting that steaks and chicken dishes are equally dependable.
In addition to the menu, Cafe Adirondack features nightly specials.
Many reviewers mention returning again and again, which may be the highest compliment any restaurant can earn. Others emphasize how Cafe Adirondack feels like a “hidden gem,” especially for visitors who don’t expect such a polished dining experience in a small Adirondack hamlet.
The service is often described as professional yet personable, reinforcing the sense that guests are genuinely welcomed—not rushed, not overlooked.
A Pottersville standout worth seeking out.
In a region filled with diners, taverns, and seasonal eateries, Cafe Adirondack stands out by doing the fundamentals exceptionally well. It doesn’t chase flash or novelty; instead, it focuses on quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and a dining experience that feels both comforting and special.
Whether you’re passing through Pottersville, staying nearby, or planning a dinner worth the drive, Cafe Adirondack delivers the kind of meal that reminds you why certain restaurants become local institutions—and stay that way.
For more information, visit Cafe Adirondack’s website.
Where to stay, shop, eat, and experience near Pottersville.
Shop for unique Adirondack apparel, gifts and merchandise.
ADK Talks Podcast
Love the Adirondacks? You’ll love our podcast. We take listeners beyond the guidebooks and into the heart of the Adirondacks. We share stories from the people behind the best places to eat, shop, stay and explore in the ADK. Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Authentic Irish pub with an Adirondack twist in Schroon Lake.